Oh The Irony

Well now there’s an odd thing. I think about Marion Zimmer Bradley for the first time in ages and re-post my musings on Rediscovery and not two days later I heard about the accusations made against one of my adolescence heroes by her daughter. Yes, I know, I’m about a month behind everyone else again, as Moira Greyland revealed Zimmer Bradley’s abuse at the end of June. I now feel what some British friends of mine must have felt when Rolf Harris was accused. I don’t know what to believe but I see no reason to doubt Greyland. Zimmer Bradley reveals strange ideas about sexuality in her novels – strange perhaps because they are set in different worlds but, in the light of the revelations sinister as well as strange.

Alyssa Rosenberg wrote an article for the Washington Post which I very much agree with and which could be extended to the Darkover novels. The idea of women being wedded and bedded without as much as a by-your-leave is horrible and, thank God!, governments have pledged themselves to end forced marriage. Yet on Darkover the idea is condoned even by apparently strong women for ideas of duty. Almost ironically, on Darkover rape is also seen as the ultimate crime – but only when committed against a Keeper, a female ‘sorceress’ (for want of a better term) who, it is believed, must be chaste to fulfill her duties. I have always thought that Zimmer Bradley’s ideas on sexuality were slightly strange yet other ideas, as I mentioned in my previous post, are great. Rape and abuse are a constant theme in the Darkover novels, yet they also deal with the psychological consequences of the crime. Yet this woman is also an author who writes with apparent understanding of the pain and the shame of being a victim of sexual abuse – only think about the Renunciate Guild, a guild where, it is said, all women have a story and no story is happy. Camilla n’ha Doria, one of the protagonists in the Renunciates Saga, had herself neutered because of sexual abuse. Having been raped she had no desire to feel feminine and desirable for men, yet her love for Magda helps her overcome the shame and the painful memory. The contradictions are evident which make the revelations even more ironic.

There is no doubt about her importance as an author, a female author in the sci-fi and fantasy genre. I can only echo the words of Jim Hines, who wrote ‘her magazine helped a lot of new writers, and her books helped countless readers. All of which makes the revelations about Marion Zimmer Bradley protecting a known child rapist and molesting her own daughter and others even more tragic’. Tragic is a good word. I love her stories, I love Darkover but child-abuse is an offense so horrific that I am rendered speechless. From an academic’s point of view this revelation gives me a new insight into her novels and ideas. As a young woman who read Zimmer Bradley’s work at an impressionable age I feel betrayed and ashamed – and can only say to Moira Greyland that my thoughts are with her because I cannot begin to imagine what she went through and is still going through. She emailed the Guardian saying she thought fans would be ‘angry’. I am angry that Zimmer Bradley wasn’t reported sooner, that Greyland had to go through this and that she should feel obligated to her mother’s memory. Yet the memories of other friends and collaborators reveal Zimmer Bradley to have been a friendly and loving person. I feel that a discussion of such a thing as ‘the dark side’ of a human being is too philosophical for this post, so I will leave it there. I am glad Greyland has found support after her revelations and I hope that it helps in the healing process.

Links to the articles I mentioned and to the Guardian’s report:

The original email from Moira Greyland is posted here on Deirdre Saoirse Moen’s blog: http://deirdre.net/marion-zimmer-bradley-its-worse-than-i-knew/

Alyssa Rosenberg, Washington Post: http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/act-four/wp/2014/06/27/re-reading-feminist-author-marion-zimmer-bradley-in-the-wake-of-sexual-assault-allegations/

Jim C Hines: http://www.jimchines.com/2014/06/rape-abuse-and-mzb/

Guardian: http://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/jun/27/sff-community-marion-zimmer-bradley-daughter-accuses-abuse


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s